Hi. If you were to right click on the play tab, I have both "shuffle randomly" and "shuffle tracks by album" ticked. Under preferences, I have selected "random" and "group by album."
Under the play now list (in preferences), I have both "If playback is stopped" and "when tracks are playing" as PLAY NOW. Under "'Play Now' action: I have "clear list and play all tracks" selected. Nothing else under under the "now playing list" is selected other than "highlight playing track" "and scroll it to the main panel."
Come to think of it, I'm not entirely sure what Play Now means... Perhaps part of my trouble has to do with this? I tinkered with the other options, but I couldn't figure out how to fix the problem.
As I mentioned before, I'm pretty sure some of the playback settings changed in one of MusicBee's more recent editions (perhaps as far back as version 2). If there is a way to set the preferences to fix my problem, I'm not sure how.