I'm sorry, I thought I made that clear.
I've played many times with the playlist settings, trying different things, but have not been successful so far. Was hoping that someone would point out the really obvious setting that I somehow missed the first thirty times. :/
Right now, the closest I have is:
Path has value.
Play Count is less than 1.
Album is any of [insert list]
Date Added is in the last 1 days.
It works...-ish. But would love if someone has a better setup.