7. One more improvement suggestion for Tagging tools:
Replace: Tools /Tagging Tools / Show Files with Missing Tags with
Show Files with Tags to EditYou mentioned once that You are going to implement similar feature for Artwork, but my suggestion is more general.
Let 'Show Files with Missing Artwork/Lyrics' remain as the options work great and are very useful, but all other inconsistencies in tags should be moved to the new menu entry 'Show Files with Tags to Edit'.
The main advantage of this solution would be that a user could determine by oneself the criteria to include the Tracks to Edit. It could be based on tag ratings, assigned to all tracks in the Library automatically in consideration of the score for every tag value/field.
For example:
Total score for perfectly rated track would be 100 points = max value after summing up all the partial components scores.
One of the partial components could be
Lyrics - weight - 10 points, but 0 points when there is no lyrics for the track, and 5 points when there are some mistakes in the text (specified by the user manually)
Another could be
Artwork - weight - 15 points, but
- max 8 if Artwork size is less than specified by the user;
- 0 - when there is no Artwork for the track (assigned automatically with MB based on tag values).
Another component could be
Year,
Album Title - 10 points if the tag field is updated, and 0 if not.
And so on.
Compare how it works with Rapid Tagger (freeware):
User could choose easily, which tag inconsistencies are most important for him to fix by assigning higher rating score to selected tag values/fields. If an Artwork size is less than a value specified by the user, the track would score less in Tag/Artwork field, but it would still be included to edition alongside tracks with no Artwork.
I know that the screenshot doesn't fully cover the idea, but I think it could be inspiring.
