Author Topic: MusicBee, MediaMonkey, Sonos and the ENSEMBLE tag  (Read 1428 times)

Gyroscope

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 1
First up, this isn't a complaint. MusicBee is the best product out there for organising music, and I use it every day. Rather this is really just a tip for anyone who runs into a similar situation because it took me a while to get to the bottom of it.

For background, my music library is nearly all FLAC, and it lives and dies on "Album Artist". If I'm not sitting in front of a PC I use Sonos for playback.

Call me weird, but I have a few surrogate album artists for compilations and mixes, to avoid clogging up "Various" with hundreds of albums. So, say, I've filed a few albums under "Warp Records" for compilations from, err, Warp Records.

Hence I occasionally tweak the Album Artist tag.

A while back I noticed that while I had four compilations filed under "Pete Tong" for the "Essential Selection" series of mixes, in my Sonos app two showed under "Pete Tong" and two showed under "Essential Selection". I could remember buying a couple of the albums fairly recently, ripping them and deciding that "Pete Tong" was probably the best place to file all of them, along with two existing albums originally filed under "Essential Selection", so I had changed the album artist on the pre-existing albums.

I re-scanned the library with Sonos. No change. Deliberately changed the album artist to something foolish in order to touch the timestamp on the files, changed it back. No change in Sonos.

Long story short I found that the ENSEMBLE Vorbis comment was set on the old albums, and still read "Essential Selection". I deleted these tags, rescanned with Sonos and suddenly everything was fine.

On scanning the entire library with mp3tag, filter "ensemble PRESENT", I found that the tag was set on about 14,000 files (sad face).

As best I can piece together, I used to use MediaMonkey up until about a year ago. MediaMonkey writes both the ALBUMARTIST and ENSEMBLE tags with the same value. I have no idea why.



MusicBee doesn't normally touch the ENSEMBLE tag. So if you edit the Album Artist in MusicBee on a file previously touched by MediaMonkey the tag gets orphaned. Sonos not only reads the ENSEMBLE tag, but prefers it over ALBUMARTIST.

It's an easy fix to nuke the broken tags, and it's rare that I change an album artist at all, but it had me confused for a good while.