Hi,
back in the 1990s, when MP3s etc. were still far from ordinary I occasionally was presented with burned CDs from my friends which I subsequently used to rip into my computer using EAC or the like.
My question is:
How good would the quality of these "rerips" be? My guess is that even when the second rip is done carefully there still could be problems because the music has already been compressed in the first rip.
How do you deal with such music?
Thanks!
If the burned CDs were simply copies of other CDs (in other words, the friend copied the CD directly without any processing done to the files), then the sound quality on the burned CD will be exactly the same as if it were a store-bought CD. If you were to rip those to MP3 now, it would be exactly the same as ripping a bought CD.
If the CDs were made from MP3 sources (in other words, the friend has some MP3, converted those to WAV and then burned those WAV files to CD), the sound quality on the CD will be MP3 quality. In the 90s, 128kbps MP3s were pretty standard. They will sound compressed on the CD. If you were to rerip those and compress them to MP3 again, the sound quality will be absolutely terrible.
Double compression like this is never good. 320kbps->WAV->320kbps may be somewhat listenable. 128kbps->WAV->anything will be filled with compression artifacts (a garbly sound).
Very basically, V0, V1, V2 refer to the Lame Variable Bitrate Preset used when converting to MP3. Variable Bitrate means more bits are used for more complex passages and less for less complex passages. V0 is the highest quality variable bitrate preset, and V9 is the lowest. You can also rip to Constant Bit Rate, using the same number of bits to compress simple passages as you do to compress complex passages and wasting a lot of space in the process. Read phred's links for the technical details.
Programs like Audiochecker (
https://www.freewarefiles.com/Audiochecker-Beta_program_21299.html) and Lossless Audio Checker (
http://losslessaudiochecker.com/#downloads) try to guess whether a file is from a lossless (CD / FLAC, etc) source. In other words, if you rip a CD to wav or flac and put the wav or flac into those programs, it guesses if the source of that file is lossless. It checks how much information is present in certain frequency ranges in the file that should be present in lossless sources but are missing due to compression in MP3 files. There is some debate as to how reliable this method is, but I've found it works reasonably well.