Your suggestion:
+ Really effective with (color) variation of the same skin
- We have to keep the same icon set for all skins
- We can't choose exactly which color we want for our icons (which color your option gonna choose as the base color? What I mean is your option is great if you want the same color for every element on the tool bar)
iasc & scampbll suggestion (not mine, btw):
+ We are able to have different icon design sets, not only color. It doesn't mean that you have to create a different icon set for each skin. Just want a color variation of the same icon set? You can. That's why I don't understand your sarcasm and what I'm missing.
We could have something like this:
<element id="ToolbarIconsFolder">Flat Design</element> Just select the same forlder for each skin if you want the same set
<element id="OverrideToolbarIconsColor" fg="255,255,255" /> This way, you don't have to edit icon one by one when you just want a color variation
+ We can choose exactly which color we want for our icons
I just read 2 suggestions in this topic and wrote which one I prefer. And your saying to me to "don't take it personnally"? What's about you?
I could have answered a sarcasm to your sarcasm. Then what? Do you think that if I'm sarcastic with you, you gonna understand better? No, you aren't. Same for me...
So, no, your suggestion don't have to be dismissed in favor of iasc & scampbll one. BTW, both can be implemented: your's as a MusicBee setting, the other one as a skin setting.
Just my 2 cents.