getmusicbee.com

General => MusicBee Wishlist => Topic started by: metrodub on August 16, 2019, 03:44:18 AM

Title: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: metrodub on August 16, 2019, 03:44:18 AM
I love utilizing the Music Explorer tab to find albums from Artists I am listening to or discover new acts that are similar to what I am listening to.  Plus, I'm a bit of an organization nut and tend to be a bit meticulous with tags in my collection.

I would love it if MusicBee was able to separate an Artist's main albums from albums that they appear on (either on a compilation or a featured artist on a song).

If you look at the image below, I have 25 albums (5 below the scroll) that Kanye West is on.  8 are main Kanye albums (if you exclude the collaboration with Jay-Z) and 17 are albums that he appears on.

I'm not sure how difficult it would be to implement but if you could add a header for "Main Albums", or another title, then display those albums (where the Artist is identified as Album Artist) and then have an "Appears On" header below the main albums followed by those albums, that would be an awesome addition.

I would also assume that if an artist doesn't have any "Appears On" albums, then that header would not show and vice versa.

(https://i.imgur.com/8hfFN5z.png)
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: TotamiLegend on August 24, 2019, 08:51:13 PM
+1!

Multiple sections like Spotify profiles, something that I wanted for so long!


- Albums

- Singles

- Appears on
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: Steven on August 25, 2019, 08:31:04 PM
For v3.4 In the Music Explorer, I have split Albums into a separate "Appears On" section where the criteria is the album artist differs from the current active artist selected in the Music Explorer
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: metrodub on August 25, 2019, 09:54:56 PM
That's awesome!  Thanks Steven.  Looking forward to testing it out.
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: metrodub on July 05, 2020, 01:27:24 AM
Playing around in the 3.4 alpha and the Appears On addition is perfect (as seen in the Kanye screenshot below).

(https://i.imgur.com/lJYSsiH.png)


However, if an artist is only on compilations or featured on songs within the library, the "Appears On" header does not show up.  For example, Future is on a number of songs in my library, but I don't have any of his albums where he is the Album Artist.  In the screenshot below, you can see those albums that he appears on, but the "Appears On" header if not visible.

(https://i.imgur.com/gOTgVhx.png)

Is it possible to have the header appear if the artist does not have any albums where they are the Album Artist?

Thanks.
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: Steven on July 05, 2020, 02:09:08 AM
That was intentional but thinking about some more what you propose is fine

http://www.mediafire.com/file/rkx9mn38mybdpaa/MusicBee.zip/file
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: metrodub on July 05, 2020, 03:38:31 AM
thank you!
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: Goblet on July 05, 2020, 07:06:58 AM
Is there any option to toggle this? It's a nice addition but I'm not huge on it personally.

I have a lot of collaborations in my library and this shunts a ton of them into the "appears on" section. I had a look around in the sort sections and couldn't figure out any way for album artists to be split similar to the normal artist tag.  

(https://i.imgur.com/m4wtRMm.png)
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: Zak on July 15, 2020, 10:35:20 AM
It looks like this is taking into account the extra credit tags like Remixer, GuestArtist etc. which is great.


However, further to the previous post, it doesn't work if the Album Artist tag has multiple artists.

For example, I have "Trent Reznor; Atticus Ross" as Album Artist for "The Social Network" soundtrack, but that album still appears under Appears On for each of those individual artists.
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: Goblet on July 15, 2020, 12:32:11 PM
It looks like this is taking into account the extra credit tags like Remixer, GuestArtist etc. which is great.


However, further to the previous post, it doesn't work if the Album Artist tag has multiple artists.

For example, I have "Trent Reznor; Atticus Ross" as Album Artist for "The Social Network" soundtrack, but that album still appears under Appears On for each of those individual artists.

I did make a separate post about this as there hadn't been any activity here, but this is a pretty big issue for scores where collaborations between composers is relatively common. I'd understand if this were down to faulty tags on the part of the user, but that's how these albums are officially credited. Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross are a fantastic example as they always collaborate on scores.

94/241 of my Hans Zimmer albums are in the appears on section, with the majority being collaborations. Nearly every single composer I have in my library (Zimmer, Giacchino, Williams, Morricone, Elfman) has some number of collaborations on scores.
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: metrodub on July 15, 2020, 05:59:25 PM
If you change the view from Artist to Album Artist you will essentially remove the Appears On grouping.  However, you then have separate instances for each of the collaborations.

I'm not sure what the happy medium is for this.  Maybe it's a change in the coding logic or maybe it's, as Goblet recommended, an option to toggle this feature.



Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: Goblet on August 31, 2020, 03:33:25 AM
Gonna bump this. I think this needs a bit more consideration as it really breaks the flow of the music explorer. I'm fully on board with the idea behind it for features and such, but collaborations are quite common -- especially for composers -- and this is quite disruptive.
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: Steven on August 31, 2020, 09:27:25 AM
does this version work better?
https://getmusicbee.com/patches/MusicBee34_Patched.zip
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: Goblet on August 31, 2020, 10:29:16 AM
does this version work better?
https://getmusicbee.com/patches/MusicBee34_Patched.zip

Thanks for the reply Steven. I can't see any differences myself

EDIT: I should clarify I'm talking about the most recent posts on this topic regarding collaborations between two artists in the album artist tab causing normal albums by an artist to be put in the appears onn section, not the addition of the appears on section itself
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: Steven on August 31, 2020, 10:45:51 AM
i wont be able to help further with this
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: :finalsound: on September 05, 2020, 09:20:20 AM
does this version work better?
https://getmusicbee.com/patches/MusicBee34_Patched.zip

Thanks for the reply Steven. I can't see any differences myself

EDIT: I should clarify I'm talking about the most recent posts on this topic regarding collaborations between two artists in the album artist tab causing normal albums by an artist to be put in the appears onn section, not the addition of the appears on section itself

My first post with a little problem ... My Music Explorer is sorted by artist. With 2 (or more) artists the, album artist is "Artist 1 & Artist 2" and so on. Under Artist I use the "Multiple Artist Splitter" (// ).
Since this update I have unknown fields under the Appears On field. These unknowns only appear if the artist is also represented on a compilation (iTunes Compilation Flag, VA) and "Multiple Artist". Everything is fine with multiple Artist without a compilation or artists without a "Multiple Artist" and compilation... With "Multiple Artist" and compilation now I have 4 fields with:

1: Appears On - Compilation
2: Unkown - Artist 1 & Artist 2
3. Appears On -Compilation
4. Unkown - Artist 1 & Artist 2.

https://i.imgur.com/8qMYNP8.jpg


Now my question and my wish. Where do these unknown fields come from? Is it possible to separate "normal" albums and compilations?

Thanks
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: Goblet on September 05, 2020, 03:39:44 PM
i wont be able to help further with this

It's a bit disappointing to hear this but I understand. Hopefully you reconsider in the future as I have to imagine this'll be more of a widespread issue than it seems. I really like the idea behind it for features and such, but it lumps collaborations into the same category which is a bit off in my opinion. My library is unusual in that it's dominated by score albums where collaborations are more common (meaning this crops up constantly for nearly every single one of my artists), but scores aren't a niche type of music as it stands. Cheers for the reply regardless.
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: Steven on September 06, 2020, 06:38:10 AM
Since this update I have unknown fields under the Appears On field. These unknowns only appear if the artist is also represented on a compilation (iTunes Compilation Flag, VA) and "Multiple Artist". Everything is fine with multiple Artist without a compilation or artists without a "Multiple Artist" and compilation... With "Multiple Artist" and compilation now I have 4 fields with:
can you send me a link to your settings file (help/ support/ view settings)

edit:
actually i can see an inconsistency in the sorting that may be causing this issue for you. Could you try this version:

https://getmusicbee.com/patches/MusicBee34_Patched.zip
unzip and replace the existing musicbee application files
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: :finalsound: on September 07, 2020, 07:32:24 PM

Hello Steven, thanks for the quick response. With the new patch the problem is solved. Thank you very much ... have a nice week.
Title: Re: Music Explorer: Separate Main Albums from Appears On Albums
Post by: Goblet on October 11, 2020, 03:15:25 PM
I figured it's intentional so I just wanted to say thank you Steven for making the Music Explorer's appear on section split the multiple album artists correctly. It really makes a huge difference. Your dedication to MusicBee is just awesome and it's by far one of my most used programs.

I wanted to ask if you could possibly take into consideration how this section handles custom sort values? I have a couple artists in my library that've changed their performing name, and whilst I use the custom sorting option to redirect the artist's name and merge their discography fine, any album that doesn't match the merged name will go down into the appears on section.

I may be explaining it incorrectly so I'll add some screenshots and give an example. Composer Junkie XL has been going by his real name, Tom Holkenborg, more recently. As a result I use the multiple artist splitter / custom sort values to sort Junkie XL as Tom Holkenborg. This works perfectly for everything outside of the appears on section, as whilst it'll recognise the individual tracks as ones he's worked on, it won't match to the album artist.


https://i.imgur.com/YCdQoW6.png
https://i.imgur.com/h6w4Jbt.png

Just wanted to float it, no big deal if you can't. It's a pretty minor issue and quite rare I have to imagine.