getmusicbee.com

Support => Questions => Topic started by: Stamimail on January 03, 2017, 11:52:33 AM

Title: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: Stamimail on January 03, 2017, 11:52:33 AM
Looking for best program for private\custom tagging
http://www.techsupportalert.com/content/best-free-music-players-and-organizers.htm#comment-125555

"Tag by a click"
http://www.techsupportalert.com/content/best-free-music-players-and-organizers.htm#comment-128375

Thank you,
Stamimail
Title: Re: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: Phaedrus on January 03, 2017, 01:05:54 PM
I could see that being incredibly useful, but not for everything.

I could see this as a drop down list for fields that only have a few possible options. Possibly something like Genre, but only if your Genre list is short. If you have to scroll through 50+ menu items, I don't see much advantage with a larger library. If this were the case, have it populated with values already listed in the database only. I'd use it for something like "Mood" or "Occasion."

I could also envision a custom field that is a check box or radio button. Something like; "Kid Friendly" or "Don't play this one at work."
Title: Re: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: CritterMan on January 03, 2017, 05:06:58 PM
1) Read up on custom tags: http://musicbee.wikia.com/wiki/Custom_Tags (http://musicbee.wikia.com/wiki/Custom_Tags)

2) No Idea.
Title: Re: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: Stamimail on January 03, 2017, 05:41:55 PM
Exactly like you can edit the Rating (stars) while playing a song, I'm looking for ability to apply a custom tags by a click.
This idea is similiar idea to Gmail tags/labels. The same concept.

Another thought is to make it in such a way it could be found by Windows Search. Is there appropriate mp3 tag for this mission, making custom tags could be found by Windows Search?
Title: Re: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: psychoadept on January 03, 2017, 05:47:07 PM
I'm pretty sure a "toggle" setting for custom tags has been requested before.  That's about the only thing I could see being useful without being very complicated to implement.
Title: Re: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: Stamimail on June 23, 2020, 02:38:59 PM
Hi,
I'm still looking for a "while-playing" tagger. Does anyone know if such a thing exists?
As mentioned, the only "tag" that can be edited "while-playing" is the stars (Rating).
I want an app, that will let the user to type-in custom-tags, that will be added to app as balloons (label buttons).
While playing you can edit the balloons (enable/disable) by click, in a similar way to the stars.
Later, you will be able to search and play or make Playlists, based on those customs tags.
Title: Re: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: hiccup on June 23, 2020, 03:10:22 PM
If I understand you correctly; the vertical tag editor will allow you to do that.
(View > Arrange Panels)
Title: Re: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: psychoadept on June 23, 2020, 08:50:23 PM
Custom tag data types (which are configurable in Configure Fields) include Enumerated, which means you pick from a list (the list is generated from existing values in that tag), and Rating, which I think works exactly like the normal rating except the value is saved to custom tag. For enumerated, you'll still have to save the tags after applying. Not sure about rating.
Title: Re: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: Stamimail on June 23, 2020, 09:10:13 PM
If I understand you correctly; the vertical tag editor will allow you to do that.
(View > Arrange Panels)
I can't find the similarity between:
the vertical tag editor
and
the stars at the seek bar (bottom part of MusicBee) - which you can "tag by a click"

I'm talking about a panel that can be an alternative for the main panel.
I think all the custom tags can be added to one custom tag of the track, as a one long string with delimiters.
Something like:
custom1: [@MusicBeeTaggingCode:@1__Guitar;2__Piano;3__MusicForMorning]

While playing a track - labels will be displayed in the main panel:

Track Tags:
Code
[[x]Guitar]  [[x]Piano]  [[x]MusicForMorning]
Add Tags to the track:
----------------------------------------------
Search for Tag: [___MusicFo_______]
[MusicForPark]
[MusicForEvening]

List of Tags:
[iPad]
[iPod]
[iPhone]
[MusicForPark]
[MusicForEvening]
[Violin]
[Saxophone]
[Sea]

Add new Tag to list: [_______]



The goal:
To add/remove tags by a click (or doubleclick) while a track is been playing.
The applying doesn't have to be immediately, it can be when moving to the next track.
Title: Re: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: psychoadept on June 23, 2020, 10:46:23 PM
Well, the advantage of the vertical tag editor is that it will always be displayed (or you can dock the regular editor in the main panel for the same effect). I really think an enumerated tag is going to be your best bet. That way you can click in the field, check the items you want, and save. You only have to type in the field if you need a new value.
Title: Re: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: psychoadept on June 26, 2020, 03:11:13 AM
This is where you can find Configure Fields: https://musicbee.fandom.com/wiki/Tracks_View#Configure_Fields
Title: Re: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: Stamimail on June 26, 2020, 03:25:54 PM
I tested it a little.
Yes, indeed it make it easier to tag while playing.
But still the concept is a little different.
Currently, in the enumerated tag way, the tag list is based on what is exist on other tracks. Whenever removed from other tracks then is removed from list. You can't clear all the Custom1 tag from all tracks, and start over to tag by the list you had before.
BTW, it is not so intuinteive to configure, and I think it's not work 100% well:
1. The "Configure Fields" button is is placed far away from the "vertical tag editor"
2. Rating type didn't work well for me. It's not editable.
3. There was annoying "Confirmation" dialog-box each time you edit. You can't edit freely, song by song, with just one (or two..) click.
4. i think the list database is not live updated. I needed to Exit and Run MusicBee again to find the new tags I'm editing, really added to the list.


As described before, I'm talking about a new tagging mode, where the tags list database doesn't depend on the tags of the current library's tracks. It is independent, and managed by the user.

I think it's important to make a distinction between
Information tags, which basically give details about the song. Those are the normal tags, and supposed to be fixed.
and,
Customizable tags, which are things that can be changed by the user's mood.

I also think that the Information tags need to be saved to the files themselves, and the Customizable tags need to be saved to an external database, among application settings files.

I would happy to see such tagging mode in MusicBee in future.
Title: Re: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: hiccup on June 26, 2020, 06:37:07 PM
I think I can imagine some implementation where this could be useful, but I see some problems in the way you are describing it.

Quote
1. The "Configure Fields" button is is placed far away from the "vertical tag editor"

I don't understand what you mean by far away. In any implementation you will need to navigate to some configuration panel to set and edit things up to your personal preference.
So what is far away here?

Quote
2. Rating type didn't work well for me. It's not editable.

What is rating type?

Quote
3. There was annoying "Confirmation" dialog-box each time you edit. You can't edit freely, song by song, with just one (or two..) click.

What you find annoying here in my opinion is a sensible warning/confirmation. But a request to be able to bypass it could be valid.

Quote
I think it's important to make a distinction between
Information tags, which basically give details about the song. Those are the normal tags, and supposed to be fixed.
and,
Customizable tags, which are things that can be changed by the user's mood.

I also think that the Information tags need to be saved to the files themselves, and the Customizable tags need to be saved to an external database, among application settings files.

That's a different matter, and I don't agree with what you are saying here.
The distinction between 'information tags' and 'custom tags' is not that simple, and neither of them are a completely objective matter.
Many users will prefer to have their custom tags enclosed in their files.
If they were only externally stored in some specific MusicBee installation it would be quite easy to lose them forever.
Also, you can already choose how you want to save your custom tags. So I am not sure how this relates to your question/proposal.

-

You will also need to consider and propose some user interface for what you have in mind.
After you have now discovered  the functionality of the vertical tag editor; do you propose some enhancements for it, or do you have some completely new panel in mind?
How would that look, and how would it function differently from the vertical tag editor?
Title: Re: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: psychoadept on June 26, 2020, 06:48:04 PM
3. There was annoying "Confirmation" dialog-box each time you edit. You can't edit freely, song by song, with just one (or two..) click.

Are you talking about the one that says "One or more value have been amended"? Yes, as I said, you have to save after changing the tags. There are hotkeys for Save and Save/Go To Next, to speed it up.
Title: Re: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: Stamimail on June 30, 2020, 10:22:01 PM
You will also need to consider and propose some user interface for what you have in mind.
After you have now discovered  the functionality of the vertical tag editor; do you propose some enhancements for it, or do you have some completely new panel in mind?
How would that look, and how would it function differently from the vertical tag editor?
I have some completely new panel in mind.
I think the initial chart I drew here (https://getmusicbee.com/forum/index.php?topic=20632.msg176530#msg176530) is enough. It should get perfected.
Note: The [ ] specifies a button: might be with x for remove, and might be a TextBox... it's self explanatory.
Sorry for the CODE part. I needed to put that text in CODE due to Forum limitations combining x in [ ].

Are you talking about the one that says "One or more value have been amended"?
Yes. Still I think this idea requires a new panel rather than enchantments in vertical tag editor.
Title: Re: Can I have your opinion about this idea - "Tag by a click"?
Post by: SpirosG on July 03, 2020, 11:56:39 PM
I found this idea pretty clever actually and it would save a lot of time for DJs like me.
I usually write comments to my tracks this requires some time to write them but if we have this kind of panel with "custom" tags ready to be inserted by one click will be a life saver

in the image bellow you can see some of my comments, adding them by a simple click would be amazing.


(https://i.imgur.com/6qno9Yb.jpg)