getmusicbee.com
General => MusicBee Wishlist => Topic started by: getmusicbee_account1111 on November 02, 2023, 04:40:06 PM
-
As was figured out in https://getmusicbee.com/forum/index.php?topic=40135, there is indeed some sort of inference algorithm. A toggle to disable it would be nice.
I think it would even make sense to disable it by default. Tags shouldn't get autofilled or pseudo-autofilled without letting the user know. Not to mention, if the user really wanted something displayed, they'd set the filename as a display field which the inferred tags are pull from anyway.
-
-1
-
Tags shouldn't get autofilled or pseudo-autofilled without letting the user know.
-1
MB will never autofill tags unless the user tells it to. By default MB does not do this.
-
If I understand what this is all about, I don't think it is something that will affect users that use MusicBee as intended.
Meaning that if you at least have your artist and title tags in order, this would never be any kind of issue.
So it's probably something the vast majority of MusicBee users will not care about. (same as me)
It was also never raised by any MusicBee user in the past 10+ years.
But…
I am also against software presenting things as facts while they are not.
MusicBee inventing an 'Album Artist' when there actually isn't one is one example that I have been boring this forum with for a long time, and more then once.
And I won't stop now ;-)
So for the sake of trying to be consistent:
+1
If a user does not care to put effort in tagging his music properly, or he does, and leaves specific tags blank on purpose, let MusicBee just display the facts.
And not decide or assume what a user should see.
Isn't that why most of us have such a dislike for software by companies such as Apple?
"You don't really need to know, and you don't want to know or do 'that'. We're only helping you for own your sake. We know what's best."
-
Tags shouldn't get autofilled or pseudo-autofilled without letting the user know.
-1
MB will never autofill tags unless the user tells it to. By default MB does not do this.
I definitely didn't tell it to, and neither did the other user, yet it autofilled them. If you'd like you can try reproducing.
If I understand what this is all about, I don't think it is something that will affect users that use MusicBee as intended.
Meaning that if you at least have your artist and title tags in order, this would never be any kind of issue.
So it's probably something the vast majority of MusicBee users will not care about. (same as me)
If the intended userbase will always have those two tags populated then why have this feature to begin with?
-
I understand the logic behind support for this feature, but on the other hand, I believe eliminating it will lead to more stupid posts, clutter and work for the forum moderators.